Crisis Care and Restoration Pathways

Have you ever felt like you’ve blown it? Maybe as a father or a mother, as a son or daughter. Maybe you felt like you’ve blown it as an employer, or employee, as a friend. What I’m referring to as “blown it” is rooted in a standard that you or someone else has set that you did not live up to the expectation and the feeling you get when you’ve let others down. Perhaps you’ve blown it as a student and failed miserably on a test or assignment. Maybe you felt like you’ve blown it in a job interview, when you arrived 15 min late and without a call informing of your tardiness. I’m sure if we think about it long enough, we can find multiple examples of how we’ve “blown it” in our lives before. The chances are your pastor feels the same way at times.
Your pastor may feel like he has blown it in the ways he has tried to care for families. He probably doesn’t have the perfect marriage, or parents his children correctly all the time. There will be times when he may lose his temper and is short with someone. There will be times your pastor will let you down. The simple fact is we all are susceptible to failures that may disqualify us from leading because we are a fallen humanity.
One of my favorite pass times is track and field officiating. I am a Master Certified Official with USA Track and Field; I also officiate NCAA college meets and even high school meets. No matter what venue I work, there is always someone who will inevitably be disqualified from an event either due to a false start, a handoff outside the exchange zone or a runner not staying in their lane causing impeding on another athlete. When a DQ occurs on an athlete, the coach will usually protest at first but then shifts the attention to the athlete and reaffirms them and coaches them on the things they need to correct in order to do better next time.
Before God, all of us were disqualified. There is a DQ next to every one of our names, next to every single one of us, from plumbers to poets to physicians to preachers. We are not nearly good enough. Even on our best days and in our brightest moments, we fall incredibly short of God’s holiness. But God in his great love and grace for us does qualify us. He does for us what we cannot do for ourselves. If you are His, if you have received His forgiveness, He has qualified you.
If grace qualifies us, then why use the term disqualified? The reason I use this term, is because it has an edge to it. Disqualified is a sharp word, it isn’t an ambiguous word. It’s the kind of word that elicits a response from people. In thirty years of ministry, I have observed men and women in organizational leadership expected to be leaders with character become disqualified for leadership because of moral collapse.
In the Scriptures the Lord, uses Paul to tell Timothy of clear qualifications for leading others in the church. Consider 1 Timothy 3:2-7 An overseer, therefore, must be above reproach, the husband of one wife, self-controlled, sensible, respectable, hospitable, able to teach, 3 not an excessive drinker, not a bully but gentle, not quarrelsome, not greedy. 4 He must manage his own household competently and have his children under control with all dignity. 5 (If anyone does not know how to manage his own household, how will he take care of God’s church?) 6 He must not be a new convert, or he might become conceited and incur the same condemnation as the devil. 7 Furthermore, he must have a good reputation among outsiders,1
One can be qualified by His grace and disqualified to lead at the same time. To be disqualified from leading in no way contradicts the beautiful reality and the glorious news that grace qualifies us. Disqualification for issues of character is always preceded by an implosion of integrity. By a leader falling apart internally before the ruin and rubble is seen externally. Churches must be prepared not only to respond to crisis but to do so redemptively.
In his book How to ruin your life Eric Geiger makes a wonderful connection of what led to the leadership failure of King David. He discusses the three explosives of Isolation, boredom and pride that ultimately led to David’s moral implosion. 2 David was alone and became vulnerable, he had sent his friends away. He was bored with his life and routine and decided for something else to look at, something else to conquer, something else to pursue. He found Bathsheba. The friends who would have stopped him were nowhere around. Finally, David’s pride got the best of him, when he thought I am king, I get what I want. Pride corrupted his heart.
Our implosion may not look like David’s, but our implosion can have similarities. We may experience burnout and emotional collapse, moral failure, trauma, grief. All of which may leave us compromised and unable to fulfill our leadership duties. These implosions can have ripple effects on our relationships and our ability and credibility to lead our churches with confidence.
When a congregation has a leader who may be disqualified for leadership what is the church to do? Churches would do well to have a crisis response plan. The response plan is designed to prevent church conflicts and to aid in a level of care to biblically restore individuals back to the fold of God. Far too often, churches have taken the posture of discarding pastors and staff and for that matter members over conflicts where someone has been let down or offended. By creating a crisis care team we assist in minimizing the damage from the offense.
Talking to other people about a conflict can be unpleasant. We unintentionally build tensions to the exploding point and then confront people with a list of their wrongs. The person we attack becomes defensive and shoots back a list of our wrongs, which leads to a painful battle of words. There has to be a better way to communicate with others about their failings.
In his book Resolving Everyday Conflict Ken Sande suggests that we look for the opportunity to restore. The Bible clearly says there are times when you need to address other’s short comings. We need to be ready to confess our own contribution to the conflict and help others own their part.3 We are to help be a peace maker; consider Galatians 6:1 Brothers and sisters, if someone is overtaken in any wrongdoing, you who are spiritual, restore such a person with a gentle spirit, watching out for yourselves so that you also won’t be tempted.4
Part of the crisis plan needs to involve other partnerships to assist when the offense or conflict is beyond the capabilities of the team members. In these cases, I suggest partnering with your local association and mission strategist. Sometimes you need the assistance of your Ky Baptist Convention. On the frontlines of the state convention are the Regional Consultants that can help you navigate the conflict resolution and mediation between the pastor and the church. It is possible that you may uncover an ugly situation that could be criminal and may require local authorities to be involved. Having the right partnerships in your crisis care team can help navigate those issues with you.
An essential step for your crisis care team is to determine, how does one receive restoration after they’ve blown it. In all cases restoration involves repentance. Consider the example of David, after his sin was brought to light by Nathan. When Nathan confronted David, Nathan assured him that his sin was already taken away. David was already forgiven because he belonged to God, yet David still confesses his sin. He desired his relationship with the Lord to be restored.5
Even when we have been restored by God, doesn’t necessarily mean that our actions are without consequence. It is very possible that our personal implosion will have damaging effects that will last a lifetime. The purpose of a crisis care team is to help find restoration and a re-entry into Christian service. Redeemed people practice redemption and look for opportunities to restore. Your implosion doesn’t need to be the end of your story. Plan to help others prevent personal implosions and help recover them when they do.
1 Christian Standard Bible. Holman Bible Publishers, 2017.
2 Geiger, Eric. How to Ruin Your Life: and Starting Over When You Do. B&H Books, 2018. Pg27
3 Sande, Ken, and Kevin Johnson. Resolving Everyday Conflict. Baker Books, 2011. Pg 73
4 Christian Standard Bible. Holman Bible Publishers, 2017.
5 Geiger, Eric. How to Ruin Your Life: and Starting Over When You Do. B&H Books, 2018 pg. 75






Comments